Mobile site
Stay here
Why book with us?

Why book with us?

It pays to book with Smith.
Literally.

Find out how

Smith Money Back

Free membership

Want money back, gifts on arrival and exclusive offers?

Join now

Boutique hotels in Shelter Island

Mr & Mrs Smith has visited romantic boutique hotels, chic and stylish B&Bs and five-star luxury hideaways in Shelter Island, to bring you a handpicked selection of the best boutique hotels in the area.

Don't want a hotel in Shelter Island? Search somewhere else
  • £
  • $
  • €
0000031398_listing

Sunset Beach

Hamptons, United States

  • Style Breezy beach house
  • Setting Sedate Shelter Island

Like St Tropez in miniature, Sunset Beach attracts a who’s who of the Hamptons to its stylish island environs.

Doubles from
Book now
If you haven’t entered any dates, this rate represents the cheapest double room (excluding tax) that can be booked in the next available 21-day period.

Prices have been converted from the hotel’s local currency (USD325.00), via XE.com, using today’s exchange rate.